What's a good "semi-dumb" phone/watch for kids?

When choosing a "semi-dumb" phone or watch for kids, the key features to prioritize include no open internet/app store, whitelist-only contacts, GPS tracking, SOS/emergency functionality, and durable design. Based on current options (as of Q3 2024), here are my top recommendations:

Top 5 Semi-Dumb Devices for Kids

1. ·Verizon GizmoWatch 2 – Best overall balance with voice calls, GPS, SOS, and strict no-app/no-browser restrictions. Requires a carrier plan (~$5/month).
2. ·TickTalk 4 – Adds Wi-Fi video calling (parent-controlled) alongside standard watch features. Higher upfront cost ($150).
3. ·Relay Phone + Watch – Ultra-simple push-to-talk walkie-talkie style device with no data/camera. Best for young kids.
4. ·Nex-Go Kids Phone – Basic GSM phone with call whitelisting and SOS. Good for older tweens needing phone functionality.
5. ·Garmin vívofit jr. 2 – Activity-focused watch with no calling. Ideal if communication isn’t a priority.

Key Decision Factors:

• ·Age: Under 8? Relay or GizmoWatch. 8-12? TickTalk or Nex-Go. 12+? Consider a locked-down smartphone.
• ·Budget: Under $100/year? Relay or carrier-watch. Over $150? TickTalk.
• ·Features: Need video? TickTalk. No internet? Relay or GizmoWatch.

Setup Tips:

• ·Use a shared family plan to save costs.
• ·Enable geofencing and test alerts early.
• ·Teach SOS button use via drills.
• ·Regularly audit call/logs for anomalies.

Bottom Line: For most families, the GizmoWatch 2 (or carrier equivalent) strikes the best balance. If video calls are needed, TickTalk 4 is the safest choice. For strict simplicity, Relay is unmatched.